Member-only story
Defensive Looping
Defending The Loop
5 min readJun 6, 2025
✅ Reasons to Replace or Unroll a for
Loop
🔧 1. Dynamic Loop Control
Need to Skip or Break Midway Based on Complex Conditions)
Problem: for
loops define the loop control in one place and expect it to change in a predictable pattern.
❌ for
loop (gets messy):
for (int i = 0; i < 10; i++) {
if (some_weird_condition(i)) { // while in come compilers, the i value can be changed when exiting the function, and in some it remembers by popping the stack
i += 2; // Looks like it skips, but...
}
printf("%d\n", i);
}
/**
* loop variable in a for loop behaves differently depending on whether:
1. The compiler optimizes it into a register, or
2. It’s updated after function calls or stack frames
*/
🧨 The Problem in C/C++: for
Loop Hides the Real Control
❌ Why this is misleading:
You think you're increasing i by 2 to skip ahead. But at the end of the loop, the i++ still happens, so the manual i += 2 gets overridden or muddled.Also, depending on optimization, i may be cached in a register, and modifying it may not reflect as expected if some_weird_condition exits early or changes context (like returning from a nested function).